Monday, 28 October 2013

Scotland and HS2

HS2? What is it?

Basically its a new  'High Speed' rail line planned for England, it's planned start point will be London Euston - phase one will terminate at Birmingham while phase two will see the line snaking its way to Leeds and Wigan.

I mention it for two reasons, the first far less bothersome than the second - its mentioned on the BBC's online news page for Scotland...


Years of Disruption. It goes without saying...
... and its going to cost in total £42.6 billion - yes, BILLION - of which Scotland will be paying a per capita share of £4.8 Billion. (I took the liberty of rounding the figure up, I think its safe to do that since the estimated cost of the project will no doubt rise anyway.)

For the avoidance of doubt.



Illustrated most ably by the map from the BBC's web page, HS2 doesn't go much further north than Leeds. Leeds isn't in Scotland, heck, Scotland isn't even shown on the map the BBC chose to use in their story and yet - to paraphrase Alan Bissett - 'but you'll pay for it, you'll pay for it'. 

Transport is devolved to Holyrood, the current Minister for Transport is Keith Brown, his budget comes from the block grant which in turn is worked out with the Barnett Formula - no yawning at the back - HS2 on the other hand is supposed to benefit the entire UK so Scotland won't receive an equivalent per capita share of this transport spending (which is how Barnett is supposed to work.)

(Very quickly: Barnett is a fag packet calculation on how Holyrood and its devolved responsibilities are funded. Put simply, if Westminster spent £100 on paperclips for England, Scotland - with ~9% of the population - would get £9 to spend on paperclips , or what ever we thought best suited our paper-collation needs. This is horrifically over-simplified, but I'd challenge anyone to try and make sense of the wiki page on the subject. If you do figure it out, please clue me in.)

Same as it did for London's new 'super sewage system' costing £4.2 Billion. Scotland should have got something in the region of £400 million in line with Barnett, instead though, we got to pay our per capita share of a sewage system 560 miles away from Inverness.

If Westminster decides a project will benefit the entire UK, instead of Scotland getting its per-head share of spending, it gets a per-head bill instead.

Not only will you and your kids be paying for a railway line which comes no where near Scotland - recently, an unintended consequence was discovered - not only will people in Scotland be paying for it, we'll be penalised by it. 

That Aberdeen (for example) could lose out to the tune of £220m - this is to do with companies potentially choosing to locate to areas served by HS2 instead of the North East of Scotland - wouldn't have seen the light of day were it not for an FOI request passed over to the BBC, (sometimes they do their job.)

Only under the current Westminster arrangement is it possible for a person living and working in Dundee say, to be paying for a train line in England which will potentially cause the company they work for to relocate or for future job opportunities to evaporate because of that self-same train line Westminster forced them to pay for.

Indeed, it seems, if you live in Scotland and want something approaching your fair share of the tax revenues you contribute to the UK's coffers - you need to visit London for a dump. 

Not wishing to sound dramatic about this but, there must a few jowly old men in clubs around London - pigs snuffling at the trough of the British Hyena State - laughing like drains over brandy and cigars. They are simultaneously taking the piss with London's new super sewage upgrade which Scotland helped pay for and taking Scotland for a ride with it's massively costly, doubtfully beneficial new high speed train set.

What more do people need to know for next September and why - seriously - why would you vote to maintain this iniquitous settlement?



* Edit for clarity. It isn't wrong to say the rail line will come no where near Scotland - it won't, at least not until the nebulous phase 3. The trains however, according to the HS2 website, will continue 'seamlessly' onto the East Coast Line (for example) to Edinburgh - one assumes the trains won't be able to travel at the same break neck speeds that it does south of Leeds. Its a fine point, we're still paying for a rail line in England, Scotland's benefit will by in the form of time saved when the train gets onto the new line at Leeds.

It's still not blowing my skirt up.

Friday, 25 October 2013

To the people of Dunfermline who voted for the Labour candidate

This

this

and this.

It's not that I don't have the words, I do, I really do, several in fact, each one more foul than the last.

Its just that for some, it seems like if we have to explain (and it seems like we do) they'd never understand.















Friday, 18 October 2013

Big Six UK utility companies

What are the 'Big Six' then? They are the six main companies we in the UK have very little (as in no) choice but to buy our gas and/or electricity from.



Managing director - Chris Weston.
Brutish Gas, sorry, I meant British Gas is a subsidiary of Centrica who's operating profits in the six months to June 2013 were £1.58 billion. In order to assuage this terrible lack of profit, they recently raised energy prices by 9.2%. You can see why their Managing Director looks so content.

Centrica also own Scottish Gas.




CEO Vincent De Rivaz
EDF, is wholly owned by the French state-owned EDF SA (Electricitie De France if you're at all interested and yes, there should be acute accents over the e's, but who knows how you do that?) EDF haven't as yet announced their price rises for this winter, last year's though were an eye watering 10.8% (assuming your eyes can water with the heating off.) 

In his spare time, Vincent De Rivaz enjoys photographing the frozen corpses of old age pensioners, (I'm joking, I have no idea if he does that. Please don't sue me like you tried to sue those environmental activists who climbed the chimneys of your power station at West Burton, not that I think you did it to scare off any future protests because as we know; EDF is a fair and responsible* energy supplier.)

I've blogged (irreverently) about EDF before, only click if you have time you don't mind not getting back.

* Daily Mail Online alert.




CEO Tony Cocker
E.on is a German owned power company who's UK arm was formerly known as Powergen. Apparently it used to be a vertically integrated Utility company, I've linked to the wiki page for an explanation about 'vertically integrated' things but lost interest before it finished loading.

E-on were famous earlier this year for a 14.7% jump in profits (to £273m) for the first half of 2013 after it raised prices in January 2013 by 8.7% for dual fuel punters. The profit alluded to above was made by their 'Supply Division', but their UK power generation and oil & gas business saw profits fall sharply, from £399m to £159m. I mean give them a break, they've got to make the short fall up some how right?

E-on haven't announced their price rise yet, charitably, they wait till we're right in the middle of the cold snap to do their robbing.

And no, I'm not saying anything about their CEO's last name.



CEO Paul Massara
RWE npower plc, trading as Npower, is a UK based German owned gas & electricity supply and generation company. Npower not only supply electricity they also make it - so to speak. While that isn't very interesting, it is important because if a company is set up just so, it can hide huge profits made in its supply division in the way it trades internally with its generation division.

For example, if your newsagent hiked the price of a Cola Bottle from 1p to 10p then told you - "sorry, its the supplier" - the shop's profit stays the same but the supplier's profit goes up substantially - what you don't see is he is his own supplier.

Last year, npower announced an increase in profits of some 34%, this in the same year they hiked prices for gas by 15.7% and for electricity by 7.2% (although the kind souls dropped the price of gas by 5% at a later date.)

Npower owns nine power stations across England.




CCO Scottish Power and CEO of Scottish Power Renewables, Keith Anderson
Scottish Power is another vertically integrated utility company, headquartered in Glasgow but owned by Spanish giant Iberdrola. Iberdrola employs 38,000 odd folk around the globe and enjoyed profits of €2.8 billion in 2012. Scottish Power is truly vertically integrated - it operates the distribution network for Merseyside & North Wales and is also the Transmission Owner for the south of Scotland - it also generates and sells electricity and gas to the UK. 

Remember the newsagent and the Cola Bottles? It would mean he owned the shop, the factory plus the haulage company used to deliver the Cola Bottles and the roads the lorries used. At each stage a profit margin is maintained - all of it compounded then added onto the final bill which eventually ends up with you.


A Cola Bottle, and its not even fucking fizzy,

Scottish Power's profits doubled from £350m to £712m  in 2012, in October of 2011 they hiked their energy prices by 7%. They also payed their Spanish parent company a dividend of some £890m, looking at Keith there, you begin to get ideas about where to put the vanes on that model turbine.

So far they haven't announced price rises for this year but it seems to be fashionable so brace yourself.



CEO Alistair Phillip-Davies. No, the image isn't mis-aligned, its just a long picture of APD
with a white cat in a snow storm to his right.

SSE plc formerly known as Scottish and Southern Energy plc head-quartered in Perth (Scotland, not Australia.) Other brands they own which you might recognise are Southern Electric and Scottish Hydro. With 9.6 million customers they are second only to British Gas who manage to rip off a staggering 20 million domestic and commercial customers.

SSE announced price rises of 8.2% from the 15th of November 2013 and enjoyed pre-tax profits to end of March 2013 of a lung-emptying £1.4 billion - yes, billion - and that was after it paid a record £10.5m OFGEM fine for misleading customers.

There is no white cat in that picture above, its just a middle income family shrouded by a blanket of snow.

But listen, lets not form any unfortunate views, Alistair Phillip-Davies does have a heart. As CEO of SSE he's given his staff energy discount - worth a hefty £144 - to charity. He said it just wasn't worth the bother of the 'pointless criticism'. He went on to say he 'wanted to make SSE as well-loved a brand as John Lewis'.

Aye, you're doing a fine job there right enough...

For an at-a-glance overview on the 'Big Six' click here. Hopefully, being able to put a face to those ripping you off so enthusiastically will offer some form of catharsis. Equally, when you turn on the news and hear of the first pensioners who so feared the thud of a utility bill on the hall carpet they died of exposure or hypothermia - you can look at the images above and wonder about their humanity.

For a not-very-good explanation about Futures Trading (which is why they try to convince us their prices must go up) click here, or not.

Up to you.